Thursday, May 19, 2011
Landing
Miki's not outside, nor can I see an ATM with a Cirrus symbol. I join a queue to change money and suddenly she's right there. We head for the shuttle bus for the fast boat to Kobe.
Japan is just four generations out of a feudal society. As the port bus pulled out, the uniformed, white-gloved who had shepherded us on board, stood on the curb bowing low to it. At the harbour two dock hands slipped the fast boat's lines and bowed horizontal as the boat pulled out into the bay.
Osaka Bay is splattered with boats and ships beneath a big sky. Through the haze, we can make out the occasional tall building on the horizon.
We disembark at Kobe airport, catch the Portliner into town. Masae meets us. At her flat we flake out. We awake at dusk and take a walk around the neighbourhood. Back at the flat, Masae conjures a meal of vinegar-soaked beansprouts with chicken marinated in tea and a firefly shrimp salad -- unbelievably good.
Heading East
At the departure gate for Osaka, an old woman gives me an origami bird she has made.
The flight looks full: I'm sandwiched between two other passengers. But it's not and we soon get ourselves sorted out with an entire row each. An easy flight. I settle down to read the same stories -- written quite differently -- in Le Monde and the International Herald Tribune.
Leaving Manchuria, we kink around North Korea, and cross the peninsula south of Seoul to approach Honshu. Below, the land is mountainous, the mountains forested, the flat land a jumble of fields and buildings. No open farmland in sight anywhere: scarcely a field without at least one building in it.
Friday, March 19, 2010
Big Brother fears over new medical database for all
Letter published in Hampstead & Highgate Express 18 Mar
Your headline article “Big Brother fears over new medical database for all” warns us about the Dept of Health helping itself to our confidential medical records, “presuming” that we consent, and reluctant to hear about it if we don’t.
A few of us have life-threatening medical conditions and will gratefully sacrifice some privacy for more informed treatment in A&E. For the rest of us, this is yet another demand to put private information in official hands we should by now know not to trust.
A misleading DoH leaflet ‘Changes to your health records’ assures us “anyone who has access to your records… must be directly involved in caring for you”. This is just untrue. The Department’s own documents show that government officials and many others will have access “in the public interest”, “by statute” or by court order. Those who have been paying attention will recall that the notorious Clause 152 which nearly made it into last year’s Coroners & Justice Act would have empowered Whitehall to share any information with anyone, anywhere, in or out the country for any reason it saw fit. Your readers have heard how Helen Marcus’ found the DVLA selling her registration record. Whitehall trafficks in data, and doesn’t think it needs to account to anyone for what it does.
Most us should now instruct our GPs that the DoH does not have our consent. Without such instruction, our GPs are obliged to pass on our medical records. The unhelpful and misleading circular from the DHS provides no form for opting out. But the NO2ID campaign has provided one at http://www.no2id.net/downloads/SCR_optout_sheet.pdf and so too has the NHS Confidentiality Campaign at http://www.nhsconfidentiality.org/. (You might print a copy for readers who have no Web access.)
Managing whom we trust and with what information is just part of life. We have to consider who will respect our confidences, and how they will understand and use what we tell them. The notoriously leaky database state insists on as much trust for hundreds of thousands of officials as for our family and closest friends. People in our lives have to earn our trust. Whitehall just declares itself trustworthy, in the face of all evidence. Your readers will know what to do.
Tuesday, November 24, 2009
Sooo mid-twentieth-century
Parliamentary democracy? Sooo mid-twentieth-century. Who needs MPs to say what the people think when we can read their emails, intercept their phone calls, track their movements, analyse who they associate with, and what they read, watch and listen to?
Statewatch and the Transnational Institute have published a report NeoConOpticon on the EU’s “full-spectrum dominance” domestic, corporate and military surveillance project.
Orwell’s 1984 reminded readers in a parliamentary democracy what their future might hold. Now that future is emerging, and his title mocks us. Anxieties about liberty? Sooo mid-twentieth-century.
Mourning parliamentary democracy
“Graham Allen MP”, writes Anthony Barnett at OurKingdom, “has tried harder, with more patience and less thanks, to get Labour to embrace genuine democratic reform than perhaps any other member of his Party, not to speak of his fellow MPs. Now, as yet another Committee reports on how the Commons could be reformed, ePolitix has just published his stark, bitter reflection, asking whether we need (or deserve) a parliament at all.”
Parliament is sick and decaying – and neither the government nor the media want it to recover.
…
Government is the unelected incubus which needs parliament only in order to cloak itself in its electoral legitimacy. Policy innovations, holding to account, balancing government power, securing value for money all these functions are no longer in the legislature’s remit, and haven’t been for many decades.
…
Although the media have joined the clamour for a clean-up, the last thing they want is for a clean-up to succeed.
A weak, despised parliament suits them only too well. They can win readers and audiences with eye-catching stories of scandals over expenses.
Read the full article.
Friday, September 11, 2009
The real threat to the life of the nation
From David Marquand’s wonderful Britain Since 1918: The Strange Career of British Democracy, Lord Hoffman’s ‘thunderous opinion’ striking down the internment provisions of the 2001 Anti-Terrorism Crime and Security Act:
This is a nation which has been tested in adversity, which has survived physical destruction and catastrophic loss of life. I do not underestimate the ability of fanatical groups of terrorists to kill and destroy, but they do not threaten the life of the nation. Whether we would survive Hitler hung in the balance, but there is no doubt we shall survive Al Qaeda … . The real threat to the life of the nation, in the sense of a people living in accordance with its traditional laws and political values, comes not from terrorism but from laws such as these. That is the true measure of what terrorism may achieve.
A privilege to have him as a neighbour.
Friday, August 07, 2009
The dignity of the king
In […] a democracy, the ordinary citizen is effectively a king, but a king in a constitutional democracy, a king whose powers are merely formal, whose function is to sign measures proposed by the executive. The problem of democratic legitimacy is homologous to the problem of constitutional democracy: how to protect the dignity of the king? How to make it seem that the king effectively decides, when we all know this is not true? What we call the ‘crisis of democracy’ isn’t something that happens when people stop believing in their own power but, on the contrary, when they stop trusting the elites, when they perceive that the throne is empty, that the decision is now theirs. ‘Free elections’ involve a minimal show of politeness when those in power pretend they do not really hold the power and ask us to decide freely if we want to grant it to them.
Slavoj Žižek, “Berlusconi in Tehran”, London Review of Books, 23 July 2009
Thursday, June 18, 2009
John is John

Just another John?
‘Freeborn John’ Lilburne,
17th-century champion
of civil liberty.
“So prosecute me.”
David Hume once remarked that the English had the least national character of any people in the universe. Perhaps this was a cunning Scottish put-down, since character is just what the English pride themselves on. They may not bestride the world in intellect, cuisine or emotional intimacy, but these fancy pursuits can be left to foreigners, and don’t count for much compared to their own moral robustness. At the core of this moral character lies the spirit of liberty: liberty not as the lawlessness of the anarchic French or the self-realising Geist of the high-minded Germans, but liberty as the right to be cussedly, bloody-mindedly oneself. ‘John is John,’ as Tony Blair wryly murmured of John Prescott when he punched a demonstrator, suggests something of this tautological quality.
This brand of liberty is not in principle opposed to authority, not least because without its minatory presence it would have nothing to grumble about. Even so, it keeps a wary eye on the potential insolence of power. It is peaceable but nonconformist. English freedom consists in the right to be as daft and dotty as you want. The Irish may wear the green, but the English wear red noses. They do so as a degenerate, depoliticised version of what Ben Wilson describes in this book as ‘the stubbornly independent little man … rebellious peasants, Puritans, Cromwell’s yeomen, Wilkesite rioters, Paineite radicals and trade unionists’.
What Price Liberty? is an erudite, eminently readable account of British liberties from the Stuart monarchy to multiculturalism, written in the conviction that as a society we have ‘lost the means to talk about liberty’ and need urgently to rediscover it. Liberty in the 17th century was thought to be enshrined in unwritten laws more ancient than the monarchy, and thus capable of being turned against regal arrogance. Charles I could do pretty much as he liked as long as he covered his back by invoking the national interest, a ruse that might strike Britons today as vaguely familiar. But the common law, so the argument ran, had no creator, and could not be challenged by royal edict. At the core of the freedoms it protected lay the absolute security of property, a right which was also thought to predate the monarchy. Freedom, so the myth had it, was older than autocracy, which meant the latter could always be portrayed as an upstart and usurper. The robber barons and patrician grandees had plundered us of rights established by the Anglo-Saxons.
Liberty had traditionally meant not personal freedom, but freedom for certain privileged social groups – in effect, the licence of the lawless aristocrat. From Lord Byron to Oscar Wilde, the aristocrat and the anarchist have always been secret bedfellows. If the English love a character, they also love a lord, which is one reason Byron (who was literally an aristocrat) and Wilde (who was spiritually one) are held in such high esteem. It was this genteel monopoly of freedom that popular notions of collective liberty set out to challenge.
From Terry Eagleton’s review in the London Review of Books of Ben Wilson’s What Price Liberty? How freedom was won and is being lost
Thursday, April 09, 2009
A letter to my MP
It appears clear there are difficult questions to be answered about the death of Ian Tomlinson, and there must be an inquiry into it, and what responsibility the Met. may bear.
Not just into Tomlinson’s death: please get answers too about the police’s policies and practices in political demonstrations. There are worrying reasons to believe these contributed to Tomlinson’s death and, if not challenged, will lead to others.
Peaceful expression of dissent is an essential part of our society. We are unlikely to keep it if demonstrators’ lives and liberty are at risk from police action.
Supt Hartshorn, who “heads the Metropolitan Police’s public order branch” announced the police were “preparing for a ‘summer of rage’” (The Guardian 23 Feb). Alarmist forecasts such as Hartshorn’s prepare the public for policing that provokes the predicted behaviour, encouraging calls for still harsher measures. Observers at the recent G20 demonstrations contrasted the behaviour of demonstrators with the aggressive police tactics, and the combative behaviour of particular police formations. Are we paying the police to escalate public disorder?
The practice known as ‘kettling’ is most worrying. Apparently if you and I take part in a demonstration we need to be ready to be confined for hours and charged by lines of riot police.
The context for all this appears to be the steady criminalisation of protest. The police so routinely invoke powers granted to them to combat terrorism that no aspect of their work now escapes its shadow. Police ‘forward intelligence units’ openly photograph political meetings and claim their work to be routine.
We were always a better society than our policemen think we are; their work gives them the worst of us. We have always had to restrain them from their habitual view of us as either criminals or possible criminals. But by refocusing on us as terrorists and possible terrorists, they have discovered a wide indulgence.
I read that Whitelaw, as Home Secretary, scoffed at policemen seeking powers to deal with IRA bombers, and asked if they were too soft to catch terrorists without protecting civil liberties.
We cannot afford this indulgence; not the lives, and not the freedom. As Philip Pullman said at the Convention on Modern Liberty, we are a better nation than our government thinks we are.
I look forward to your questions in the House.
Wednesday, April 08, 2009
Remembering Tom Guthrie

Vera & Tom Guthrie
I’m sad to record the passing of Tom Guthrie, peacefully in Berry, NSW on 6 April.
Tom was a great spirit, a man’s man. Growing up tough in Yorkshire in the 1930s, he made his way out to Rhodesia, where he raised his family in the sun. When it came time to leave Zimbabwe, the family followed many others to a new life in Australia, which is where I met him.
He and his wife Vera stood in loco parentis to me and Stephania during our years in Australia. Christmas wasn’t Christmas if it didn’t finish with a singalong.
I last saw Tom in 2001, taking my mum on the tour of Oz she’d long wanted. We went looking for dolphins on Jervis Bay, then swam with Tom from the fine white sand of Green Patch beach.
I’ll miss Tom’s hard-won optimism and good cheer. I won’t sing with him again, but his voice still echoes in my memory. It was a privilege to know him.
Tuesday, March 24, 2009
Conor Gearty and the “convention of cant”

Conor Gearty (pictured) accuses the Convention on Modern Liberty of inflating concern about civil liberties into a moral panic. His attack is a useful opportunity to dispel some comforting illusions.
First consider his jibe a police state or a “surveillance society” or whatever the latest colourful label is. The conflation is his; no one at the Convention claimed the present ‘surveillance society’ qualifies as a police state. But David Davis made the point very well: by the time a police state has emerged there are no easy paths back. Because our surveillance society has got us most of the way there, without serious debate, conventioneers think there is every reason to make a fuss.
Gearty offers three arguments not to: things are better than they were; we conventioneers select evidence that makes things look worse than they are; and we have got things out of proportion. These arguments converge on: Things Are Not That Bad. He accuses conventioneers of a covert reactionary agenda, “cloaking the advantages of the rich in the garb of personal autonomy”.
Well, some things are better than they were. Gearty is right to point to legislative achievements such as the Freedom of Information Act and the Human Rights Act. Whatever their flaws, these are substantial advances. But they are not substitutes for ancient liberties such as habeas corpus and Coke’s “the Englishman’s home is his castle”.
To speak of ancient liberties is not to conjure a lost golden age, as he accuses. If Gearty used to subscribe to this myth, as he says, he did well to rid himself of it. He would have heard nothing of it at the Convention. (And it would be a mistake to infer from his article that he actually attended.)
I do not wish to suggest Professor Gearty flirts with ‘Whig history’. So, though there is comfort to be taken from recent legislative achievements, we shall not assume we are advancing steadily on the best of all possible worlds.
But it does raise an interesting question. How could the conventioneers possibly have such worries under a government that shepherded the Human Rights Act into law? Surely the HRA proves there is no state conspiracy to enslave us? So how could there be crisis in the home of freedom?
The short answer is that law and the courts are but one part of the constitutional fabric that protects individuals from power. It has been strengthened in recent years. But the political support that guards liberty is absent without leave. The collapse of the trade unions late last century choked a centuries-long stream of dissent. The heirs of the Workers Education Association became mortgage holders in thrall to the house-price bubble; bribed, so to speak, with their children’s money. British workers once clothed and fed the rich; now the poor of China clothe us and furnish our overpriced houses.
New Labour fought its way into the sunlight by offering a gentler form of market liberalism. Early achievements such as the Data Protection Act were part of this promise. New Labour have since been self-proclaimed pragmatists, seeking only ‘what works’. We are now seeing the consequences of government without politics, of faith in the markets. A society more rigid, and less equal. The ruined international financial system in which we lately starred. Two million unemployed and counting.
We are now well beyond complacent talk of the ‘end of history’. The government’s chief scientific adviser warns of a ‘perfect storm’ of shortages of food, water and energy. We face unprecedented challenges: to rebuild an international financial and trade system, take a grip on the deteriorating climate, husband and share the world’s resources.
We are not on course to do that. Our course is set to guard property, secure our oil and gas privileges, and repel boarders. As that becomes more and more difficult we can expect our governments to take harsher action at home and abroad, amplifying the threats we face. We have every reason to expect the executive to demand more powers to protect us.
Executive power concentrates in many forms: land owner, industrialist, international corporation, trade union – and government. Fair words on liberty always come down in practice to obstructions placed deliberately in the way of executive power. As Gearty says, the rich seek to conflate their interests with the rights of the common man. But the common man needs those protections nonetheless.
Without political support no judicial system will protect him long. Mr Babar Ahmad will serve as a case in point. This Englishman is sought by an American court over material he published here on a website. You might suppose him protected by our right to free speech. Indeed, he faces no charge here. Yet, thanks to the Extradition Treaty 2003, proclaimed without parliamentary scrutiny in the interests of dealing more efficiently with alleged terrorists, no British court can protect him. The moral panic over terrorism prevails, despite stern warnings from judges, the ex-Director of Public Prosecutions and the ex-head of MI5. Mr Ahmad has been in prison since 2005, fighting his extradition. Mr Ahmad’s last defence is the European Court of Human Rights: successive British courts have found themselves powerless to release him.
The absence of political support for liberty shows up again in Mr Ahmad’s arrest. You might have thought this worrying matter warranted a little delicacy: I’m afraid you’re going to have to come along with us, sir. Not a bit of it. Policemen broke into his bedroom at 3am and beat him up in front of his wife. He complained bitterly to the Independent Police Complaints Commission. It agreed the arresting officers had assaulted him, but breezily declined to pursue them. Unable to get his assailants disciplined or charged, Mr Ahmad found no help from British justice but to sue the police. Last week saw the collapse of their case in the High Court; they settled rapidly.
Judicial protection for liberty is vital but insufficient without a political culture that guards it. Mr Ahmad might still have been assaulted in a more vigilant society, but would have found early and vigorous remedy. The striking lack of opposition to his extradition is still a stain on our polity.
This government never set out to reduce freedom. Liberty has been collateral damage from a government and civil service that neither trusts nor respects us. See the report on government databases from the Joseph Rowntree Reform Trust, out this week. See also the UCL Students Human Rights Programme report on lost liberties. All this to general silence from the media and a Left that has forgotten its roots in restraining power.
There are signs of a growing disgust with the politics of fear. See, for example, the hoots that greeted Gordon Brown’s recent “We are about to take the war against terror to a new level”. There is a growing awareness of the need for radical changes in how the world is run. The first step is to break the drift towards authoritarianism, the second to revive big-issue politics. These may turn out to be the same step.
We have never had bigger issues to handle, never faced such upheavals. This is the ‘roller coaster’ Gore et al. have shown us we are now on, still at the start, climbing. We are set to ride it as the subjects of increasingly authoritarian and desperate governments. Or, just possibly, as citizens mending our world. That starts – as it always has – with reasserting our liberty.
Stephen Taylor was the London event manager for the Convention on Modern Liberty.
Friday, March 20, 2009
Balkanised music
Balkanised music would be what you get when you take a modest band fee and split it between a cartload of musicians. Appears someone had their phone out and took a short video of the Orkestra del Sol playing at my birthday last year.
And in another YouTube post of their song “Important Moments”, the band recounts how they were formed.
Sunday, March 08, 2009
Why privacy matters
We fail to defend our privacy because we fail to understand it.
The word privacy doesn’t suggest anything very important. Perhaps it suggests the cosiness of a sitting room with the curtains drawn, the luxury and comfort of a private space in which one can do what one prefers neighbours to know nothing of.
We acknowledge that we – well, others – should be free to indulge our – well, their – weaknesses in secret. We do not press such a right for ourselves, having, of course, nothing to hide. But we allow that a free and tolerant society should not insist on shining a spotlight into every corner.
Nothing of this tolerance survives the demands of public security. If finding dangerous enemies means less privacy for those cheating on their wives, well, so much the worse for privacy.
This complacency rests upon a fundamental misunderstanding of the role of privacy in our lives.
Even the most truth-loving among us learns early in life to be thoughtful about sharing information and to consider the consequences of doing so. People get things wrong, draw erroneous conclusions, take things the wrong way. And then there are those who will distort or spin to take advantage of our disclosures.
Learning how to manage this is just part of becoming a responsible adult. We learn to be thoughtful about to whom we entrust information. We learn whom to trust with confidences, whom not. Only a child or a lunatic operates on the principle that “if I have nothing to hide I have nothing to fear”.
To repeat: managing issues of trust and information is a normal and essential part of living as a responsible adult.
And the converse is true. If you are prevented from managing whom you trust, you are prevented from living as a responsible adult.
The last person an adult chooses to confide in is someone who cannot keep a secret. The Civil Service is that way; labelled so by the Government’s own inquiries into data protection in public service. It has no prospect of reform in the short or medium term. The Government’s own commissioners recommend the obvious strategy: since the Civil Service cannot secure confidential information, it should have as little as possible in its hands, and as briefly as possible.
Whitehall’s actual “Transformational Government” programme, manifest in the National Identity Register and many new laws, requires us to treat the Civil Service as the most trusted of our confidants, and to delegate to it power to decide who else is to be trusted with our secrets, with or without our consent. They already regard us as either children or lunatics.
Privacy is not about unobserved space behind chintz curtains. Privacy is about our relationship as responsible adults with a state that professes to serve us but is working quite systematically to infantilise us.
Clause 152 defeated?
Today’s Observer: ‘Straw bows to pressure over data sharing’ seems to report the removal of the notorious Information Sharing Orders from the Coroners & Justice Bill. Phil Booth of NO2ID says it’s so.
Oh happy day, caloo calay.
A light shines in Buckinghamshire
To Beaconsfield to stomp around the beech woods of rural Buckinghamshire under the tutelage of the Time Out Book of Country Walks.
We burned off a good breakfast and were hungry when we arrived at the White Hart in Chalfont St Giles. Here the decor was an excellent guide to the cooking: stylish in a distracted way, and overpriced. The town is visually everything one wants from a country walk.
We knocked and were admitted at the cottage of John Milton, to be instructed by its curator. My education nodded at Milton but passed him by. I now know I must read him him to understand Geoffrey Hill and in these naughty times should also explore his views on what it takes to live as a free person.
So I was excited to hear our host speak of a revival of interest in Milton. Are others floating in these same currents? No, I was reminded, last year was Milton’s 400th anniversary. I had innocently supposed the study of a poet as serious as Milton protects against a certain frivolity of mind; apparently not.
Deep Quaker country this. Must look into the Society of Friends, the long-persecuted heirs of the Levellers, Independents and Fifth Monarchists.
A satisfying twelve miles, a nap in the car, then to Holland Park to dine memorably with Anne Tupker & Phil ‘Bomber’ Harris, who are now entertaining as a couple, bless ’em.
Tuesday, March 03, 2009
Sunday, February 15, 2009
Don’t get it yet?
For those still struggling to see why this event is important and urgent, a video mash-up from the Convention on Modern Liberty on 28 February.
Most tickets already sold by now: get yours today.
Thursday, February 05, 2009
Republic of two
Why watch so many films? (I sometimes ask myself.) Our collective dreams interest me more than my own do.
There is some part of the Landmark Forum (a self-development course), taken, I think, from Gestalt Therapy, that invites participants to imagine which fictional character would make their ideal partner. There is almost always a man who nominates Sigourney Weaver’s Ellen Ripley from Alien
This, and the proliferation of action heroines – think Angelina Jolie’s Lara Croft and Milla Jovovic & Michelle Rodriguez’s characters from Resident Evil – marks a sea-change in how relations between the sexes are imagined.
First to note is that not only are these women no longer prizes to be shielded and rescued, they have virtue in the classical sense: they are brave, steadfast, smart. It is they who see and shoot straight, confound the enemy, save the world. The best of their men are only their sidekicks.
Even the profoundly misogynistic and phallocentric James Bond franchise is changed. Tomorrow Never Dies saw Michelle Yeoh join him in action; last year’s Quantum of Solace had him collaborating with Olga Kurylenko’s Camille, who was seeking a vengeance of her own.
Jolie’s Lara Croft is not only a female virtuous man, she has also assumed James Bond’s former ease, dispatching villains with a grim twinkle and a quip. Daniel Craig’s Bond has not inherited this confidence from his predecessors; he is, as one reviewer put it, ‘an anxious gym bunny’.
This reflects the decline in men’s confidence reported in a recent survey, attributed to an increasingly feminised world in which the ‘soft skills’ of communication and collaboration outgun male traditions of command and control.
All men may be brothers, but we are paying attention to our sisters in new ways. The idealised brides on our screens are sisters-in-arms. “What happens,” asks Richard Gere’s character in Pretty Woman, “after the prince rescues the princess from the tower?” “Why,” replies Julia Roberts’s character, “she rescues him right back.”
Nothing new under the sun? There is a precedent for this, described in Alan Bray’s history, The Friend. Bray describes his puzzlement at finding the tomb of two crusading knights with their arms displayed as if they were married. Research uncovered a mediaeval tradition of wedded brothers. This was not a homosexual marriage, but a mutual swearing of fidelity, an oath to supersede all others. Wedded brothers could count on each other to death. (Compare the US Army’s ‘buddy’ system.)
Such oaths were deeply subversive, slicing across loyalties to parents and lords. The mediaeval tradition was ripe with tales of these conflicts. One, cited by Bray, tells of two wedded brothers whose fathers went to war against each other. Unable to renounce the duty each owed his father, the two took their own lives rather than bear arms against each other. These tragedies may well have been largely fanciful, but they caught the mediaeval imagination.
We can see in them the seeds of modernity. Oaths of allegiance to parents and lieges affirmed a relationship into which one was born. The wedding of brothers was chosen, a movement of the heart, and crucially given priority over all social bonds; a focus for both joy and terror. It was an oath taken and given, freely, between equals.
Nicholas Battye used to argue that romantic love was possible only between people with comparable power, which is why its paradigm in classical Greece was homosexual: think of Achilles and Patroclus, Plato’s Symposium or the surviving fragments of Sappho’s love poetry. He also argued that the mediaeval Grail romances, such as Tristran & Yseult, depended upon the high status given to ‘the lady’ by the originally Arabic poetic cult brought up from Sicily by the Provencal troubadours. Without this, women could be imagined only as prizes to be taken and enjoyed: think Helen of Troy, and just about every woman in Thomas Malory’s Le Morte D’Arthur or any Ian Fleming novel.
From our modern perspective we see the tale of Tristran and Yseult as an early, albeit tragic, celebration of passion. Nicholas claimed we misconstrue it; that it was to be read as a warning against the subversive and disruptive dangers of romantic passion. But, considering Bray’s account of the tradition of wedded brotherhood, I’m inclined to think Nicholas overstated his case. The long popularity of both tragedies indicates, I think, a centuries-long yearning for the life chosen over the life given. To be loved romantically is to be chosen above all bonds of family and society, over all claims of usefulness, to be recognised – in Kant’s formulation – as an ends rather than a means.
The folie à deux of romance is the seed crystal of the democratic republic.
Sunday, February 01, 2009
Contemptible to be rich?
With the meltdown of international financial system and the left bereft of a grand alternative, it’s all up for grabs. My own experiences as a software developer have led me to working practices which seem to share much with anarcho-syndicalism and guild socialism; hence my interest in what David Marquand identifies as democratic republicanism, and its last serious exponent, the historian Richard Tawney.
I find myself unable to join the many admirers of Tawney’s cautious and heavily qualified prose style. Nonetheless, here’s a solid piece to chew on as we contemplate the implosion of what he aptly called the acquisitive society.

Richard Tawney
A formula sometimes hailed by Socialists as the watch-word of a new order is Equality of Opportunity; but the phrase may express either of two distinct – and sometimes, though not always, antithetic – ideals. The opportunities which it is desired to equalize may be opportunities to rise; to get on; to exchange one position for a succession of others; to climb, in the conventional metaphor, the educational or economic ladder. Or they may be opportunities to lead a good life, in all senses of the term, whether one ‘rises’ or not. The emphasis of the former interpretation of the phrase is on mobility. Its aim is the establishment of conditions which offer the maximum scope for individual self-advancement. The emphasis of the latter is on solidarity. The society sought by it is one in which, while individuals are free to follow the bent of their talent or tastes, the impulse to seek a new position is not sharpened by exasperation at unnecessary disabilities attaching to that already held, and in which the majority of men are happy to continue in familiar surroundings, because they enjoy in them, not only economic security, but the dignity, the social contacts, and, if they please, the intellectual interests and culture, which human nature demands. The sentiment of the father who hopes – too often, as things are, with reason – that his son will follow any trade but his own illustrates the first view. The attitude of the worker who refuses a foreman’s job because it would divide him from his mates illustrates the second.
Individuals deprived of the chance to use their powers as they please suffer from frustration. Further, society cannot afford more than a certain proportion of fools in high places, which in England is already – to speak with moderation – sufficiently large, and must draw, if its directive work is to be efficiently done, on a broad stream of talent from below. For both reasons arrangements facilitating vertical mobility are important. It is equally or more essential, however, that the mass of mankind, who, for obvious statistical reasons, cannot perform athletic feats in scaling social heights, should enjoy a high standard of civilization. Nothing could be more remote from Socialist ideals than the competitive scramble of a society which pays lip-service to equality, but too often means by it merely equal opportunities of becoming unequal. Our aim should be the opposite. It should be to effect a complete divorce between the differences of pecuniary income and differences in respect of health, security, amenity of environment, culture, social status and esteem. Might it not, indeed, be beneficial, not only to destroy the connexion between them existing today, but to reverse it, so as to make it contemptible to be rich and honourable to be poor?
from “British Socialism Today” in The Radical Tradition, R.H. Tawney, 1966
A romantic dream – or has this year’s revulsion against the bankers and their bonuses made it once again conceivable?


