Showing posts with label romance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label romance. Show all posts

Thursday, February 05, 2009

Republic of two

Why watch so many films? (I sometimes ask myself.) Our collective dreams interest me more than my own do.

Lt Ellen Ripley
Lt Ellen Ripley

There is some part of the Landmark Forum (a self-development course), taken, I think, from Gestalt Therapy, that invites participants to imagine which fictional character would make their ideal partner. There is almost always a man who nominates Sigourney Weaver’s Ellen Ripley from Alien

This, and the proliferation of action heroines – think Angelina Jolie’s Lara Croft and Milla Jovovic & Michelle Rodriguez’s characters from Resident Evil – marks a sea-change in how relations between the sexes are imagined.

First to note is that not only are these women no longer prizes to be shielded and rescued, they have virtue in the classical sense: they are brave, steadfast, smart. It is they who see and shoot straight, confound the enemy, save the world. The best of their men are only their sidekicks.

Even the profoundly misogynistic and phallocentric James Bond franchise is changed. Tomorrow Never Dies saw Michelle Yeoh join him in action; last year’s Quantum of Solace had him collaborating with Olga Kurylenko’s Camille, who was seeking a vengeance of her own.

Jolie’s Lara Croft is not only a female virtuous man, she has also assumed James Bond’s former ease, dispatching villains with a grim twinkle and a quip. Daniel Craig’s Bond has not inherited this confidence from his predecessors; he is, as one reviewer put it, ‘an anxious gym bunny’.

This reflects the decline in men’s confidence reported in a recent survey, attributed to an increasingly feminised world in which the ‘soft skills’ of communication and collaboration outgun male traditions of command and control.

All men may be brothers, but we are paying attention to our sisters in new ways. The idealised brides on our screens are sisters-in-arms. “What happens,” asks Richard Gere’s character in Pretty Woman, “after the prince rescues the princess from the tower?” “Why,” replies Julia Roberts’s character, “she rescues him right back.”

The Friend
The Friend
by Alan Bray

Nothing new under the sun? There is a precedent for this, described in Alan Bray’s history, The Friend. Bray describes his puzzlement at finding the tomb of two crusading knights with their arms displayed as if they were married. Research uncovered a mediaeval tradition of wedded brothers. This was not a homosexual marriage, but a mutual swearing of fidelity, an oath to supersede all others. Wedded brothers could count on each other to death. (Compare the US Army’s ‘buddy’ system.)

Such oaths were deeply subversive, slicing across loyalties to parents and lords. The mediaeval tradition was ripe with tales of these conflicts. One, cited by Bray, tells of two wedded brothers whose fathers went to war against each other. Unable to renounce the duty each owed his father, the two took their own lives rather than bear arms against each other. These tragedies may well have been largely fanciful, but they caught the mediaeval imagination.

We can see in them the seeds of modernity. Oaths of allegiance to parents and lieges affirmed a relationship into which one was born. The wedding of brothers was chosen, a movement of the heart, and crucially given priority over all social bonds; a focus for both joy and terror. It was an oath taken and given, freely, between equals.

Nicholas Battye used to argue that romantic love was possible only between people with comparable power, which is why its paradigm in classical Greece was homosexual: think of Achilles and Patroclus, Plato’s Symposium or the surviving fragments of Sappho’s love poetry. He also argued that the mediaeval Grail romances, such as Tristran & Yseult, depended upon the high status given to ‘the lady’ by the originally Arabic poetic cult brought up from Sicily by the Provencal troubadours. Without this, women could be imagined only as prizes to be taken and enjoyed: think Helen of Troy, and just about every woman in Thomas Malory’s Le Morte D’Arthur or any Ian Fleming novel.

From our modern perspective we see the tale of Tristran and Yseult as an early, albeit tragic, celebration of passion. Nicholas claimed we misconstrue it; that it was to be read as a warning against the subversive and disruptive dangers of romantic passion. But, considering Bray’s account of the tradition of wedded brotherhood, I’m inclined to think Nicholas overstated his case. The long popularity of both tragedies indicates, I think, a centuries-long yearning for the life chosen over the life given. To be loved romantically is to be chosen above all bonds of family and society, over all claims of usefulness, to be recognised – in Kant’s formulation – as an ends rather than a means.

The folie à deux of romance is the seed crystal of the democratic republic.

Friday, July 06, 2007

Vanished adults

When a Woman Ascends the Stairs

To the National Film Theatre on the South Bank last night with Miki and Ruth Eisenhart to see Mikio Naruse’s 1960 classic When a Woman Ascends the Stairs. Miki reported she found this melancholy tale “encouraging” for women; I think I found it encouraging for people. The obvious reading is of the oppression of women, and their resistance to it. But it’s worth remembering that Japanese men surveyed last decade, asked what reincarnation they would choose, picked (1) a butterfly and (2) a woman. (Perhaps more of them should see this film.) I prefer a more Buddhist reading. The suffering in pessimistic Naruse’s story emerges from the difference between how the characters like to think of themselves and who they are willing to be. From the BFI’s program notes: …the preference for enlightened stoicism over glib redemption is pure Naruse.

We also enjoyed the milieu. I was a boy in the 60s. I grew up knowing this was how adults dressed. Odd dissonance now seeing the vanished adults – and they’re y-younger than me! And for Miki this was the decade before her birth. Thomas Hardy set all his novels in the decade before his birth; someone has probably studied the relationship of artists to this period in – no, before – their lives.

Anyway, 60s nightlife. Men in suits, women in beehives; cool jazz and cocktails. We were inspired. The NFT has expanded from the dark film-buff den below Waterloo Bridge that I belonged to in the 70s, and now boasts space, light, air and a smart bar with smart food and prices. And smart Negronis and the best Pimms N°1 Cup Miki’s tasted. Back to Ruth’s for tea and The World of Nat King Cole documentary – the project Carole had been working on, one supposes.

Friday, June 22, 2007

Desire and Cocktails

Cocktails last night with Marilena, Stefano & Klaus near Porta di Venezia at Lelephant, a gay bar, its apostrophe long washed away. Much to learn and observe. The Milan classic is the Negroni: Campari, red vermouth a-and what was that? Soda? No, gin. Better order another. One can make a reasonable dinner from plates of the snacks laid along the bar for Happy Hour – approx. 6-9pm here.

At the next table a tall, slender young woman has fine long hair, a child-pretty face, and hips that – every time my eyes brush across them – have my belly contract with lust. I can fan my reaction like a fire: eyes down for a flame; up and the lust fades to embers. We are talking about Scruton’s argument1 that the objects of our desires are persons not bodies. This seems to show otherwise. Those lyre-like hips don’t qualify as a person. Arguably the face better represents one. I desire the hips but not the person?

My intuition is that, like most physiology, the causal chains are more tangled. Curvy hips and shiny hair trigger a lust keyed to the fecundity they signal. This much Scruton concedes we share with animals. Desire for a person, further explored elsewhere2, is of a different order, somewhere between lust and love. ‘Sexual desire’ starts to look like a conflation. I have my own theories about desire for a person, but they don’t seem to me to explain adequately the importance of consummating that desire in sex.

Three men at her table. So she’s…? Fashionable metrosexuality, no one wants to be explicit about these things. We meet briefly at the buffet, and I pass her a napkin. This is all eyes and conversation; I could care less.

We spend a third of our lives asleep and much of the rest being run around by sex3. We have scarcely any idea how all this works. What price our vaunted knowledge?

  1. On Sexual Desire by Roger Scruton
  2. Death-Devoted Heart: Sex and the sacred in Wagner’s Tristan und Isolde by Roger Scruton
  3. Kingsley Amis on outliving his libido: It was like being shackled to a maniac for forty years.

Friday, June 08, 2007

Pavlov’s smile

Worked out why I keep catching the eye of Laura, a woman working here in the Relais Palazzo del Capitano. Every time I do so, I am rewarded with a smile of stunning radiance. (No doubt, in honour of I. Pavlov, I also drool a little.) Calls to mind fragments from an early poem of Marilyn Hacker’s:

Satisfied lovers eat big breakfasts. I
want black coffee and a cigarette to
dull this cottonmouth. …
…       Sleep and don’t smile
that crazy candlepower for a while.

Tuesday, June 05, 2007

La Vita Nuova

Here we are in Tuscany, homeland of Dante. His collection of sonnets La Vita Nuova (new life) did much for the establishment in European culture of romantic attraction as an access to transformation. Five centuries later, here’s Pynchon.

His life had been tied to the past. He’d seen himself a point on a moving wavefront, propagating through sterile history – a known past, a projectable future. But Jessica was the breaking of the wave. Suddenly there was a beach, the unpredictable… new life. Past and future stopped at the beach: that was how he’d set it out. But he wanted to believe it too, the same way he loved her, past all words – believe that no matter how bad the time, nothing was fixed, everything could be changed and she could always deny the dark sea at his back, love it away. And (selfishly) that from a sombre youth, squarely founded on Death – along for Death’s ride – he might, with her, find his way to love and joy. He’d never told her, he avoided telling himself, but that was the measure of his faith as this seventh Christmas of the War came wheeling in another charge at his skinny, shivering flank…

from Gravity’s Rainbow by Thomas Pynchon

See also my sonnet “La Vita Nuova”.

Sunday, May 27, 2007

Perhaps I can change my life

We fall in love with the people who make us whole.

Robertson Davies

Or, more precisely but less quotably, we fall in love with people we see as having access to parts of life closed to us.

This, she thought, is what being in love is like. You can recognise it by the little cold ticking of calculation in your thoughts: perhaps I can change my life.

From Imposture by Benjamin Markovits, reviewed in “Suicidal Piston Device” by Susan Eilenberg, London Review of Books 5 April 2007

Pynchon in Ireland

On my way home from the Kx Systems conference in County Clare, Ireland, with Thomas Pynchon’s Gravity’s Rainbow a thick brick in my hand-baggage. It seems I’ve decided to reread it in preparation for similarly long but far-more-rambling Against the Day, awaiting me at home. Here are characters Roger and Jessica, nesting in south London, resisting the Home Front’s intrusion into every corner of life. (Compare our own lovely ‘War on Terror’, endless absorber of outrages.)

If they have not quite seceded from war’s state, at least they’ve found the beginnings of gentle withdrawal… there’s never been the space or time to talk about it, and perhaps no need – but both know, clearly, it’s better together, snuggled in, than back out in the paper, fires, khaki, steel of the Home Front. That, indeed, the Home Front is something of a fiction and lie, designed, not too subtly, to draw them apart, to subvert love in favour of work, abstraction, required pain, bitter death.

They have found a house in the stay-away zone, under the barrage balloons south of London. The town, evacuated in ’40, is still ‘regulated’ – still on the Ministry’s list. […] It is marginal, hungry, chilly – most times they’re too paranoid to risk a fire – but it’s something they want to keep, so much that to keep it they will take on more than propaganda has ever asked them for. They are in love. Fuck the war.

From Gravity’s Rainbow by Thomas Pynchon