Saturday, January 31, 2009

Hit me!

To the Edgar Wallace pub in Essex St yesterday afternoon for the now-monthly meeting of the London chapter of the British APL Association and a pint of an odd beer from Berkshire with a smack of haggis to the taste. (Just in time, for we neglected Burns’ Night this year.)

To the Leicester Square Theatre to see Hit Me!, a bio-musical about the life of Ian Dury. I do not buy programmes as a habit, but had one pressed upon me by the stage manager Gemskii, without whose advice I should not have known that the best part was her bio at the back. Despite all the reservations one should have about hanging around nostalgic former punk-rockers it was a great show, with some sharp-as-a-tack writing. Here’s Dury soliloquising about starting at High Wycombe Grammar School.

Everyone was very nice to me at first, and over-helpful. Then they saw I didn’t need much help and thought I was a bit of a villain for accepting it. It was a bit difficult to know how to behave in that situation, so I became a right little cunt.

Gemskii had asked me my favourite Dury song. Unprepared, I had offered “My Old Man”, which is a great favourite. But the show reminded me that my very favourite remains “Sex an’ Drugs an’ Rock an’ Roll” for its last six lines:

Don’t do nothing that is cut price
You know what that’ll make you be
They will try their tricky device
Trap you in the ordinary
Get your teeth into a small slice
The cake of liberty

Convention on Modern Liberty - February 28th, London and around Britain

The cake of liberty shrank in the last decade, and the state presses us in more and more and more ways to account for ourselves and cough up information we are otherwise careful about whom we trust it with. Come on 28 February to the debate Parliament won’t hold, to assess the damage and decide what to do about it.

Get yourself a ticket to the Convention on Modern Liberty.

Wednesday, January 28, 2009

Full employment

Keith Moffitt
Keith Moffitt

To Camden Town Hall last night for a briefing from Keith Moffitt, leader of the Liberal Democrat group in Council. Afterwards, some of us decamped to Pizza Express. One of our party is thinking of getting a job. Some unsolicited advice (from me, not the chap on the right):

You are thinking of quitting the failing family business and finding a job in accountancy, or in politics, work you find agreeable and to which you sound, on our slight acquaintance, well-suited. Do not do this. Or, at least, do not do this because you find the work agreeable and yourself well-suited to it.

Instead, answer this question. If you did not need the income, what would you work on? What do you want to make happen so much that, if you needed to and could afford it, you would pay to be allowed to work on it? This is your work. Get busy at it and then figure out how you get paid for it.

How could that work? It might not. It is entirely possible you are the only person out of six billion on the planet who wants to see this work done. (Then you’d better get busy. Who else is going to handle it?) That is entirely possible. But it’s extraordinarily unlikely that you are the only person who cares about your project. Almost certainly, other people also want to see this work done. Find them, and some of them will pay you to do it. There are many ways they might do so: as customers, as taxpayers, as sponsors; heck, they might even have an organisation with a salaried role ready to employ you. But find your work first. This is the spiritual meaning of full employment.

This path is not for everyone. It is not for the many people working the Forty Year Plan. The Forty Year Plan would have you working on someone else’s goal for forty years, at the end of which you are to be paid enough to sit around, play cards and go on cruises. (The last part is not working out so well these days, but that is the plan.)

The Forty Year Plan pretends your work is a burden to be laid down as soon as you can manage. Until you can shuck off your load, you are a beast of burden. Then you go to pasture.

This is an insulting proposition, and you should reject it. We are social animals. We raise our children, who could not survive alone, and we take care of our old and our sick. We cannot and we do not manage alone. Even castaways who spend years alone survive only by the grace of salvaged wreckage, tools and manufactures: the work of others. Even the hunter-gatherers who test a young man’s ability to live alone, off the land, do not live that way. Robinson Crusoe’s story is a founding myth of modernism, the self-made and self-sufficient man, but he is a literary fiction. The reality is that we live by collaboration, by helping each other. Our work is how we relate to each other.

Whoever lives and does not work is supported by the rest of us. We all do this at times: when we are children, when we are sick. There can be nothing wrong with this; it is simply part of being human. But to be able to work and to choose not to, to withhold one’s help from others, has no virtue and no dignity. It entails an insult, either to oneself – my work is of no value – or to others – you do not deserve mine. To hold up living without working as a goal, as the good life, corrupts individuals and corrupts society.

Worse, the Forty Year Plan robs us of our work. It is no longer our work, how we relate to others, how we make our way in the world and what we contribute to others. Instead, convinced that only this way can we eat and provide, we labour on someone else’s goal, which is all too often no more than the corrupt intention to live at our expense.

Sometimes it is much worse. Hannah Arendt famously wrote of “the banality of evil” and emphasised that, while Nazi leaders made genocide their policy, administrators made it reality. It took efficient and ambitious officials such as Adolf Eichmann to run the railways and the ovens. We still have not recognised the corrupting influences of careerism and debt. As the character Nick Naylor says in Thank You For Smoking, “95% of everything that happens is done to pay the mortgage.”

More from Tawney:

Men will no longer give their labour and risk their lives for a system which they regard as morally indefensible and professionally incompetent. The alternative to it is the discipline of professional pride and responsibility – that the mine-workers should be recognized as partners in a communal enterprise, and have the power to discharge the obligations which that position will entail.

It is such a change, and only such a change, which will extricate the industry from the impasse into which it has been brought. For grave as are the technical deficiencies of the present organization which are criticized by the experts, it is not in these that the centre of the problem is to be found. The single greatest economic loss to the coal industry, and indeed to British industry as a whole, is the dissatisfaction of the majority of those engaged in it; and if it is important to increase the output of wealth, it is not a paradox, but the statement of an elementary economic fact, to say that a change which made possible cordial and constructive co-operation on the part of the workers, would do more to produce that result than the discovery of a new coal-field or a generation of scientific invention. That co-operation will not be available to swell the dividends of shareholders. It will be forthcoming only if the coal industry is turned into an honourable public service, which is carried on for the benefit, not of a class, but of the whole community, and for the success of which the workers themselves bear, in conjunction with the representatives of the consumers, an effective and increasing responsibility.

from “The Nationalization of the Coal Industry” in The Radical Tradition by R.H. Tawney, Penguin, 1964

In conversation with Moffitt: “We must restore the honour to public service; not just to politics, but to nursing, teaching, fire fighting and so on.”

Sunday, January 25, 2009

Geek chic

To The Flea Pit in Shoreditch last night for the birthday party of London girl geek Candace Partridge. The beer was good, the geek talk intense, husband and Perlmonger Paul Mison is at last happy, having been headhunted to develop alternate reality games, and the music performed on laptops by a trio of programmers using SuperCollider.

I had heard of live coding, but this was my first encounter. A projector threw on the wall, not the ‘visualisations’ of iTunes or Windows Media, but the performers’ editing windows as they modified the code.

With my interest in domain-specific languages, I was fascinated. The performers controlled what we heard not with strings, stops or keyboards, nor with the graphical user interfaces made familiar by computers, but by writing and editing, in a language devised for the purpose. We watched and listened as the sounds and rhythms responded to the changing instructions on the wall. Now I want to see it done with music I like.

Saturday, January 24, 2009

Slouching towards Westminster

Transformational Government is what the Civil Service calls its grand design for surveillance, dossiers on citizens and data trafficking. Good name that, guaranteed to flick the attention switch off.

Resistance is currently mustering around the truly shocking Clause 152 of the Coroners and Justice Bill, that gets its first reading on Monday. A younger LibDem activist asked me this morning if I thought Transformationl Guvmnt (TG) would have happened with Conservatives in power.

No doubt about it. TG is a Civil Service project, fronted by the Cabinet of the day. It springs from opportunity. The organs of the state always want such power. It is only recently that technology has brought it close to their grasp at a cost that, with a bit of dodging, might be swung on the taxpayer.

The excuses offered for barging into our private lives are the hysterias-de-jour: terrorism, paedophilia, computer fraud, immigrants. If the cameras and databases had been affordable earlier, it would have been the IRA and the Soviets. Whatever. Their vision is clear. We are to be less free and better governed. Our liberty is not their target, it is mere collateral damage.

It follows that if the next government is Conservative and keeps its promise to drag the National Identity Register out back and kill it, TG will lay more eggs in legislation closer to Tory hearts. Like the alien queen, TG and its spawn will keep coming unless and until the labyrinth is penetrated and her nest scorched.

Hence the importance of the Convention on Modern Liberty next month – to show that the nasty things scuttling from the woodwork all come from the same labyrinth, spawn of the same nest. Until we locate it and torch it, the nest remains intact. They will keep coming.

We have to get our bearings in this matter. Here’s Enzensberger.

Every orientation presupposes a disorientation. Only someone who has experienced bewilderment can free himself of it. But these games of orientation are in turn games of disorientation. Therein lies their fascination and their risk. The labyrinth is made so that whoever enters it will stray and get lost. But the labyrinth also poses the visitor a challenge: that he reconstruct the plan of it and dissolve its power. If he succeeds, he will have destroyed the labyrinth; for one who has passed through it, no labyrinth exists.

Hans Magnus Enzensberger, “Topological Structures in Modern Literature”, Sur, Buenos Aires, May-Jun 1966, quoted in Italo Calvino’s “Cybernetics and Ghosts” in The Uses of Literature

Get your ticket to the Convention.

Convention on Modern Liberty

Friday, January 23, 2009

Why I am supporting the Convention

I am supporting the Convention on Modern Liberty because I see grave threats to our free way of life in Britain. These threats do not come from terrorists. They do not come from immigration. They come from our own government.

We forget how recent and how unusual our freedom is. Our ancestors lived in what we would now call political and economic slavery, without laws or courts to protect them from the powerful. We forget that it took centuries of struggle to establish the rights and freedoms we now consider normal. The right to trial by jury, not to have our homes ransacked by officials, our mail read… they all require that those with great resources – the rich, the corporations, and even our elected government – treat us with respect.

Yes, you can lock us up – if you can convince a jury of people just like us. Yes, you can snoop on us or invade our homes – if you can show good cause to a judge. Yes, you can stop me going about my business – if you have grounds that will stand up in court. The freedom we enjoy and consider normal consists almost entirely of obstructions placed thoughtfully and deliberately in the way of executive power.

The last decade has seen more and more of these essential obstructions swept away. Each time it is done, we are offered the latest moral panic as an excuse – terrorism, computer fraud, sexual offenders, control of our borders – and promised that the exceptional new powers will be used only for those purposes, and with due discretion; and that information the government demands we entrust to them will be guarded with respect.

As our ancestors knew from bitter experience, the state is not capable of keeping such promises. The police neglect their duty if they do not use every power they have to get results; so thousands are now routinely stopped and searched each year under powers once granted to ‘combat terrorism’. When information to be held ‘in confidence’ is available to thousands of officials, secrecy is a charade; of course CDs get left on trains.

In the perspective of history, the last half century has allowed us to enjoy our freedoms in peace and comfort. In that short time we have forgotten how much it cost our ancestors to win those freedoms, to place those obstructions in the path of power. The state is now busily sweeping the obstructions away, taking back our freedoms like toys from children who no longer deserve them.

If we do not stop this, if we do not reclaim the freedoms recently taken from us, and insist on facing and tackling the problems ahead – climate, economy, energy – as free people, then the servants of the state will be right. We will no longer deserve them. And we shall, in a single generation, have squandered the free society it took our parents and ancestors three centuries of struggle to win.

Get your ticket to the Convention.

Convention on Modern Liberty

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

Get your ticket

Knowing I should not be spending £25 on a hardback copy of David Marquand’s Britain Since 1918 when my local library would find me a copy, I thoughtfully bought it for my mother, and gulped down enough before Christmas to grasp his distinction between four versions of democracy. Ruefully I recognised my heart’s allegiance to the most romantic of them, which Marquand styles democratic republicanism.

Anthony Barnett
Anthony Barnett

Helping organise the Convention on Modern Liberty, and tramping across Hampstead Heath on Sunday with neighbour Anthony Barnett, one of its directors, I confessed my allegiance. Anthony revealed that, later in the book, Marquand accuses him of sharing it. Anthony accepts the charge, but wonders how he likes finding himself in a history book. This is the kind of thing to make you feel your age.

Marquand lays the same charge against historian R.H. Tawney, and the library unearthed his The Radical Tradition. Here Tawney cites William Lovett:

Most of the reforms that have taken place in my day have been won rather in despite of the wealthy and titled classes, than owe to them their origin, though they might at last have been made the unwilling instruments for carrying them into effect. So long, therefore as those who are aiming at cheap and wise government help by vote or voice to place persons who have neither interest nor sympathy with them in the position of representatives or rulers, so long will they be putting obstacles in their own paths. The industrious classes, therefore, would do well … to resolve to do their work themselves.

The Convention is about claiming back liberties recently stripped from us. Helena Kennedy QC pressed the same point at its launch party last week, and summarises it on YouTube. Convention keynote speaker Philip Pullman wrote in The Subtle Knife:

“There are two great powers,” the man said, “and they’ve been fighting since time began. Every advance in human life, every scrap of knowledge and wisdom and decency we have has been torn by one side from the teeth of the other. Every little increase in human freedom has been fought over ferociously between those who want us to know more and be wiser and stronger, and those who want us to obey and be humble and submit.”

Know more and be wiser: Tawney and the WEA saw it as the precondition for democratic republicanism. A better knowledge of our own history, as Kennedy reminds us, would shatter the complacent assumption that the freedom we were born into is the normal and inevitable end of history. Universal suffrage, the keystone of our democracy, sought for centuries, is only decades old. History rolls on; the normal place for liberty is beneath its treads.

Get your ticket to the Convention.

Convention on Modern Liberty

Monday, January 19, 2009

His resilient career

In 2006 the Foreign Office quietly stopped using the phrase “War on Terror”. No one had the bad manners to challenge the Americans openly, but in an understated, well-bred sort of way we nudged diplomatic elbows to be sure everyone was paying attention. This is the way we Brits like to do things, you know. Diplomatic, eh? It did not stop new boy at the FO, David Miliband, from proclaiming a year ago of the invasion of Iraq, “No one is resiling from the original decision.”

Good word that, resile. Very popular with the Blair camp, apparently: a suggestion of gravity and rigorous thinking; and not too hard to spell.

Now we have resiled. The ‘war on terror’ was a mistake, Miliband says, and the west cannot “kill its way” out of the threats it faces.

Presumably the Bush Administration is too busy packing to stamp on us for this nifty piece of resiling. So no points for courage to Resilient Miliband. Nor will reversible raincoats be in fashion at tomorrow’s Inauguration Party.

Shame on you, Mr Miliband! This is the sort of thing that gives opportunism a bad name.

Friday, January 16, 2009

War on Terror

Everything comes to him who waits. In this case, the ethical foreign policy we voted for a decade ago. In an article in yesterday’s Guardian, Foreign Secretary David Miliband explains that the so-called ‘war on terror’ is a solecism. Use of this phrase has the unfortunate effect of disposing us to invade other countries when it would be wiser, and slightly more legal, to talk to them.

It is always heartening to learn one has new readers. In this case, I am encouraged enough to continue writing this column.

Still, one has to wonder. Are there no consequences to this change of view? Miliband is right to point to the poisonous effect of the phrase on our thinking. (What is it about American rigour with the word war? War on terror, war on drugs, war on poverty: may policy and program only be used for initiatives with goals?)

But we didn’t just talk about a “war on terror”, we invaded Iraq. If the invasion was based on a mistake, then the invasion itself was a mistake. Or in the plain, straightforward language we should now prefer, wrong. And wrong in specific ways, at that: a crime under British and international law. A war crime, to be precise. Mr Blair adroitly spotted this before the invasion, and briefed a legal team to analyse what case he might later be facing. So in its new-found clarity will the FO now be assisting the Metropolitan Police investigation of Blair and Goldsmith for war crimes?

Or did we all just want to ‘move on’?

Thursday, January 01, 2009

Back to work

Six months complete change and rest. Just what the doctor ordered, apart from the champagne jelly and the motoring in Egypt.

I’m back, fighting fit and ready to win in the War on Error. Let’s go.